Classification of Studies
by: Howard Arrington
Studies are used by traders to give various visual
indications of what the market is doing. Studies often
serve as the basis for trading signals and trading systems.
This article will attempt to classify studies by grouping
those that have similar characteristics.
Most studies process price data through a mathematical
formula, thus making the study results '2nd generation'.
Another common characteristic of studies is that the price
data processed is a sampled set of prices instead of every
price. The root of this characteristic is the fact that
studies process bar data values, such as a bar's closing
price. The bar itself can be a summary or grouping of many
trade prices, yet it is only the last price in the bar that
is processed by the mathematical formula.
Studies can be divided into two basic classes, those that
process prices to produce a new price, and those that
measure momentum, or the rate of change in prices. In
calculus terminology, prices are the curve and momentum is
the first derivative or slope of the price curve. The
following table lists several studies in groups under the
two primary classifications. Several of the table entries
are hyperlinks to other articles on the Ensign Software web
site where you may read more about the study.
Price Classification |
Momentum Classification |
Group |
Study |
Group |
Study |
Averages |
Simple Moving Average |
Percent |
Stochastic |
|
Exponential Average |
|
Williams %R |
|
Smoothed Average |
|
Relative Strength Index |
|
Weighted Average |
|
Directional Movement Index |
|
Volume Weighted Average |
|
Aroon Indicator |
|
MidRange |
|
Ultimate Oscillator |
|
Triple Average |
|
Money Flow Index |
|
Pesavento Map |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Channels |
Price Envelopes |
Oscillators |
MACD Oscillator |
|
Bollinger Bands |
|
TRIX Oscillator |
|
Keltner Channel |
|
Average True Range |
|
Uniform Channel |
|
Commodity Channel Index |
|
Donchian Channel |
|
Momentum |
|
Regression Channel |
|
Rate of Change |
|
|
|
Chaikin Indicator |
Stops |
Parabolic Stop |
|
Stochastic Momentum |
|
Volatility Stop |
|
On Balance Volume |
|
High Low Stop |
|
Accumulation Distribution |
|
Trailing Stop |
|
PVI or NVI Volume Index |
|
|
|
Market Facilitation Index |
Structural |
Point and Figure |
|
Ergodic Indicator |
|
Three Point Break |
|
Linear Regression Slope |
|
Price Histogram |
|
|
|
Market Profile |
|
|
|
Heikin-Ashi |
|
|
|
Divergence |
|
|
|
Auto Trends |
|
|
|
Pesavento Patterns |
|
|
Group Characteristics:
Averages |
|
Averages plot as a
continuous curve on the chart's price scale.
Averages smooth the data to remove some of the
choppiness. Averages lag behind the price
action.
Signals are often derived from the crossing
of two different average lines.
Variation: The spread between two average
lines is plotted as a histogram. This measures
the momentum of the average lines as their
spread widens or narrows.
|
|
Channels |
|
Channels typically
have a band line above and a band line below a
moving average center line. The spacing of the
bands from the center line is based on these
formulas for these studies:
- Bollinger - Standard Deviation
- Keltner - Volatility
- Uniform - Percent of Price or Fixed
Price
A Donchian Channel is a plot of the highest
high and lowest low of the last N bars.
|
|
Stops |
|
Stops plot as a
broken curve above or below the price bars.
Penetration of a stop by a price bar triggers a
reversal of the stop position.
Signals from Stops typically are more
profitable in trending markets than in choppy
markets. |
|
Structural |
|
Studies in this
group do not have a simple formula that
processes price to generate a result. Rather,
these studies rely upon a set of rules to create
the visual presentation. The logic involved in
the implementation of studies in the group is
usually complex.
Pesavento Patterns, for example, finds swing
highs and swing lows and connects the swing
points with trend lines as shown in the
illustration.
|
|
Percent |
|
Percent studies
plot on a scale from 0 to 100. They measure
momentum in the price action.
Signals are often derived from divergence
between the price action and the study. Click
this link for an excellent discussion of
Stochastic divergence.
Other signals are derived by the study line
crossing a 2nd line which is a moving average of
the study line. In the illustration, the Red
line is a moving average of the Blue line.
|
|
Oscillators |
|
Oscillators
typically plot on scales that have both positive
and negative values. The Zero level is often
positioned vertically at the center of the
window.
The study can be plotted as a curve, but is
often visually presented using a histogram.
Signals are often derived from the oscillator
crossing above or below the zero line. Other
signals are based on divergence between the
price action and the study. Click this link for
a discussion of
CCI divergence. |
|
Summary:
After 25 years of working with the markets, I do not
believe that there is a right or wrong answer as to which
studies, parameters or draw tools work the best. Each one
has its own merits, strengths and weaknesses. Each trader
needs to determine whether the insight or clue provide by
the study works for their trading style. Different trading
styles is why what works well for one trader may not work at
all for another trader.
Various mentors have a favorite study, such as
Woody likes the Commodity Channel Index study, Enthios
uses Price Histogram,
Buffy's style uses Stochastic, and
Larry Pesavento
uses the Pesavento Patterns and Pesavento Map studies.
Studies speak to them in ways that empower them to make
better trading decisions, and thus have an edge to trade
profitably.
The most innovative studies are those that attempt to
predict the market in advance of it happening. Studies in
this area typically involve neural nets and cycles to find
rhythmic characteristics in the data set and use these
rhythms to suggest the near term future. Please read the
article on
Pesavento Map for more information on predicting the
future.
Some traders use studies to help them decide when to
enter the market or when to exit a position. Others value
the studies they use for telling them when to stay out of
the market. Nothing is right all the time. Studies which
work well in trending markets typically are a disaster in
choppy markets, and vice versa. Some studies, such as the
Directional Movement Index, try to determine whether a
market is trending or choppy, but inevitably lag behind in
that determination. In other words, a study's
determination that a market is trending is only made after
it has been trending for a while, and the trend may soon be
over. Therefore, traders rarely rely solely on studies.
They also watch price action, chart patterns, divergence,
support and resistance levels, and use various
draw tools the most basic of which is a simple trend
line.
Trading Tip:
Yahoo Stock Screener
by: Paul Otteson
Yahoo is a leader when it comes to free market
information. The Yahoo Finance web site has a stock
screener with the ability to instantly screen thousands of
stocks. To view the stock scanner, click on this link:
http://screen.finance.yahoo.com/newscreener.html
Click on "Launch Yahoo! Finance Stock
Screener" link. A window opens asking if you trust Yahoo.
Click on "Yes" and the following window for the stock
screener will show.
At this point you set your search
criteria. The example illustrates doing a price search.
Click where it says "Click to add Criteria"
then select the parameters from the many options.
Click Select a Value and pick values.
After setting the conditions and values,
click the 'Run Screen' button.
This basic search yielded 1211 stocks having
prices between $10-$20. Use the 'Click to add Criteria' to
narrow your search. Rearrange the stocks by clicking on the
columns of data. Save the sheet or create a new one using
the menus at the top of the program. This stock screener is
easy to use, fast, and another great product from Yahoo.com.
This stock screener can be accessed from
within Ensign Windows (Nov 2005 version) using menu Help |
Stock Screener |