Neural
Networks, Part II
by Howard Arrington
Neural Networks were discussed in the
January 2002 issue of this Trading Tips newsletter.
This article is an update on this intriguing subject.
In June 2002, Larry Pesavento and Ensign Software signed
a cooperation agreement which began the exchange of
confidential information about the proprietary neural
network used by Larry to give him his timing signals.
Larry's method of trading uses one price tool (Fibonacci
Levels) and one timing tool (neural net forecast). Larry's
trading style was reviewed in the
June 2002 issue of this newsletter.
A neural network extracts a forecast of tomorrow's price
action by examining past data. Sounds a bit mysterious and
complex, and indeed it is. We all feel that the market
repeats itself, and accordingly use tools like cycles to
measure repetitions in time, Fibonacci to measure
repetitions in price, and Elliott waves to see repetitions
in patterns. A neural network, if designed properly, is
allowed to generalize, and through an iterative process
discover characteristics in the training data that
contribute to a useful prediction.
The objective of the Pesavento/Ensign partnership is to
design a better neural net. In order to design a better
mouse trap, one needs to thoroughly understand the design of
an existing mouse trap. Such is the case with the Pesavento
neural net. The originator of the Pesavento neural net
design back in the early 1990s was Dennis Regan (deceased)
. I wish Dennis's thoughts and reasons for why certain
things were done had been documented, but alas, such
engineering notes apparently do not exist. Therefore, Dr.
John Arrington (PhD Stanford) and I have been spent the past
couple months reverse engineering the Pesavento neural net,
testing and understanding thoroughly every aspect of its
unique design.
Now I apologize in advance that I cannot divulge all that
I have learned. I have signed a non-disclosure agreement
with Mr. Pesavento to protect the value of this intellectual
property. I will say that I have been totally surprised at
the uniqueness of Mr. Regan's design. It is something I
would never in a month of Sundays have thought of. In
comparison to the neural nets I worked with previously, Mr.
Regan's net definitely shows thinking outside of the norm.
While I cannot divulge exactly what Mr. Regan's design
is, I can tell you what it is NOT. The neural net designs
that John and I were pursuing prior to our partnership with
Mr. Pesavento, were based on training the neural net with
several weeks of past price data and generating tomorrow's
forecast using 2-minute bars. We started down that path
three years ago because the Pesavento forecasts were
overlaid on 2-minute bar charts. Mr. Regan's design is not
anything like that, and that initially really surprised both
John and I. Initially we wondered if we had the full Regan
design because it did not seem like it could possibly work,
yet it does.
The Arrington model was training with prices on the input
nodes of the neural net. The Regan model does no such
thing. It does not input prices, and that shocked us.
Instead it uses for input what I will describe as a pair of
frequencies. The analogy that John and I have used to get a
mental handle on what is happening is that of a bat's
radar. A bat bounces a frequency off an object, and
receives back a three dimensional image on its stereo
receivers. The Regan neural net is doing something similar,
bouncing frequencies from two different points in time and
space and detecting an image. We know that Dennis Regan
worked for the U.S. government on the top-secret Tomahawk
missile guidance system. Perhaps the design of the
Pesavento neural net has its roots in technology Dennis was
familiar with. That is just one of our questions that will
remain unanswered because Dennis died.
Well, we are involved in reverse engineering,
researching, thinking, trying variations on the original
Regan ideas. Progress seems promising, but all new ideas
must weather the test of time. One idea is showing
exceptional promise and was used to generate the following
forecast for August 5th. The blue line forecast was
published in advance on the
www.dacharts.com web
site on Saturday, August 3rd. I marvel at the correlation
of Monday's actual price action. I had a big smile on my
face as I watched the day progress and track the forecast.
This idea just might be something great.
Not all forecasts are of this quality and
usefulness. But when a forecast like the above comes
along, it is worth bragging about, particularly since it was
published in advance. Let me remind you the key use of the
forecast is for TIMING. For example, note the alignment of
the top turn at 8:20, the alignment of the bottom turn at
10:42, and the alignment of the top at 13:26. This is
exceptional and exactly the trading advantage Mr. Pesavento
seeks to have by using neural nets in his trading.
(Note: Forecasts may be posted occasionally
on the www.dacharts.com
web site. I do not know exactly where this project will
lead, but offer this as an answer to the frequent inquiry of
'How do I get a hold of these forecasts?'.) |