Summary
I looked at 16,664 stock market chart patterns of various types using daily
price data from 1991 to 2005, encompassing both bull and bear markets.
I found the following.
- The price velocity leading to a chart pattern often resumes after the breakout.
If price moved at a high
velocity leading to the chart pattern, high velocity would resume after the
breakout. The same is true of low velocity moves: A low velocity move after the
breakout follows a low velocity move leading to the chart pattern.
- Price drops farther (downward breakout) after a high velocity run leading to
the chart pattern, regardless
of the market conditions (bull or bear markets).
- Upward breakouts from chart patterns perform better if velocity was slow
leading to the chart pattern,
regardless of the market conditions (bull or bear markets).
Details
The following table shows the postbreakout performance of various chart patterns
in bull and bear markets, when the velocity leading to the chart pattern
(inbound velocity) was above (high velocity) or below (low velocity) the median
velocity.
The numbers show that a high velocity move leading to the chart pattern results
in superior performance after a downward breakout. Upward breakouts perform
better if low velocity leads to the chart pattern.
|
High velocity downtrend inbound |
Low velocity downtrend inbound |
Median Down Velocity
(cents
per day) |
High velocity uptrend inbound |
Low velocity uptrend inbound |
Median Up Velocity
(cents
per day) |
Bull market, down breakout |
19% |
17% |
6 |
21% |
16% |
6 |
Bull market, up breakout |
36% |
37% |
6 |
33% |
35% |
5 |
Bear market, down breakout |
26% |
23% |
12 |
26% |
22% |
13 |
Bear market, up breakout |
26% |
29% |
10 |
24% |
25% |
9 |
The following table shows
the results of a frequency distribution of how often price showed high velocity after the breakout when compared to the velocity
before the chart pattern (inbound velocity).
High velocity move postbreakout and ---> |
High downward inbound velocity |
Low downward inbound velocity |
High upward inbound velocity |
Low upward inbound velocity |
Bull market, down breakout |
62% |
39% |
62% |
38% |
Bull market, up breakout |
65% |
34% |
70% |
31% |
Bear market, down breakout |
66% |
34% |
60% |
39% |
Bear market, up breakout |
68% |
36% |
62% |
34% |
For example, the upper left
cell for high downward inbound velocity in a bull market after a downward breakout
shows 62%. That means 62% of the time price
showed a high velocity move after the breakout when the downward price trend
leading to the chart pattern also showed a high
velocity move. Just 38% of the time (100% - 62%) did a high velocity inbound
move result in a low velocity postbreakout move. The results show that a
high velocity move after the breakout follows a high velocity move leading to the
breakout.
Another example.
The cell to the right shows a result of 39% for low downward inbound velocity and
bull market, downward breakouts. That means
just 39% of the time did a low velocity, downward price trend leading to the chart
pattern result in a high velocity, downward
postbreakout move. To flip the numbers around, 61% of the time a low velocity
postbreakout move followed a low velocity inbound
move.
Definitions
The inbound velocity
measures from the trend start to the start of the chart pattern. I used the average
price at the trend start and the closing
price at the chart pattern start. (I could have used the closing price at the trend
start, but I didn’t log that into my spreadsheet).
The trend start is the lowest low or highest high before the chart pattern.
It’s the point where price changes trend
by at least 20% moving backward in time. I disregarded any overshoot or undershoot
a few days before the start of the chart
pattern.
The outbound velocity measures from the breakout to the ultimate high or
ultimate low. I used the average intraday price at the breakout
(because I didn't log the closing price) to the ultimate high or ultimate low
price. The ultimate high is the highest high
before price drops at least 20%, measured from the highest high to the close. The
ultimate low is the lowest low before price
rises at least 20% measured from the lowest low to the close. The search for the
ultimate high or ultimate low was stopped
if price closed below the chart pattern’s low (upward breakouts) or above the
chart pattern’s high (downward breakouts).
If data ended before the ultimate high or low was found, the highest high or lowest
low to that point was used.
|